The Supreme Court of India (Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran) directed the State of Uttar Pradesh to pay ₹6 lakh in compensatory damages to a man who spent six years in prison as an undertrial in a kidnapping and murder case before being acquitted. The Court heavily criticized the police for a “slipshod investigation” and “haphazard prosecution” built on unproven CCTV footage, missing Section 65B certificates, and alleged co-accused confessions. The Apex Court held that investigating agencies are essential stakeholders in the justice system who must safeguard the constitutional rights of the accused alongside victims, and directed the UP DGP and Home Secretary to educate investigating officers.
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice J.B. Pardiwala & Justice K. Vinod Chandran (Opinion authored by Justice K. Vinod Chandran)
Date of Decision: October 26, 2026
Subject Area: Criminal Procedure | Articles 21 & 22 of the Constitution of India | Wrongful Incarceration & Public Law Compensation | Section 65B Indian Evidence Act (Section 63 Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam) | Duty of Investigating Officers
Core Legal Principles Established by the Supreme Court
1. Public Law Reparation for Loss of Constitutional Liberty (Article 21)
- When a citizen’s life and personal liberty are erased by prolonged undertrial incarceration resting on a concocted or reckless police investigation, the State cannot shirk its public law liability.
- Public law compensation (fixed at ₹6 lakh with 18% default interest) is a necessary constitutional remedy to restore dignity and provide reparation to an accused who becomes a victim of the state apparatus.
2. Investigating Agencies as Balanced Stakeholders in Justice
- Investigating and prosecuting agencies exist not merely to secure convictions by any means necessary, but to act as neutral stakeholders ensuring justice for the victim, the complainant, and the accused alike.
- The presumption of innocence under Indian criminal jurisprudence mandates that investigating officers adhere strictly to procedural and evidentiary safeguards before depriving a person of liberty.
3. Inadmissibility of Defective Electronic Evidence
- Electronic evidence, including CCTV footage and Call Detail Records (CDRs), cannot form the basis of an arrest or conviction without compliance with Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (now Section 63 BSA).
- Unproved CCTV footage and uncorroborated disclosures of deceased co-accused cannot bridge fundamental gaps in circumstantial evidence cases.
Key Factual Metrics & Trajectory
| Metric / Stage | Details in Case |
| Originating Offence | FIR registered in Oct 2019 under Sec 364, 302 & 201 IPC (Agra, UP). |
| Plea & Custody Duration | Arrested on Nov 14, 2019; spent 6 years in custody as an undertrial. |
| Primary Police Reliance | Unclear CCTV footage (without Sec 65B certificate) and confession of a co-accused. |
| SC Intervention (March 2026) | Directed trial completion within 3 months due to prolonged incarceration. |
| Trial Outcome | Full acquittal of the sole accused who faced trial. |
| Reparation & Directive | ₹6 Lakh compensation payable within 1 month; judgment served on UP DGP & Home Secretary. |
Key Quotes from the Judgment
“Six years have been erased from the life of a man on the strength of a concocted story built on mere surmises and conjectures. Not even a rudimentary investigation was carried out… The investigation and prosecuting agencies exist not merely to, and by whatever means bring in a conviction. They should recognize themselves to be essential stakeholders in the justice delivery system, ensuring justice, not only to the victim, the de facto complainant and the injured but also to the accused.”
“We spent our valuable time going through the judgment only to caution the State as to the manner in which investigations are carried out. The State Police would do well to educate their officers in the process of investigation.”
— Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala & Justice K. Vinod Chandran
